Invite a friend!

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

Address
204 Van Dyke St Brooklyn NY 11231
Phone
(718) 858-5333
Is this your business?
Claim it now!
Something wrong?
Submit a correction
Average Rating
4.5
Total Reviews
(93)
Leave a review with:
  1. 1 Star
  2. 2 Stars
  3. 3 Stars
  4. 4 Stars
  5. 5 Stars
Is this your business? Claim it now!
Share on
Share

Contact Us

Email the business

Toll Free
(888) 450-5463
Fax
(256) 437-0333

Business Hours

Status: Closed

Sunday
10:00am-6:00pm
Monday
Closed
Tuesday
9:00am-5:00pm
Wednesday
9:00am-5:00pm
Thursday
10:00am-7:00pm
Friday
Closed
Saturday
10:00am-6:00pm

Additional Info

YellowBot Recommends

CHEZ CATHERINE

  • 431 North Avenue West Westfield, NJ 07090
  • (908) 654-4011

"One of the best French Restaurants in New Jersey"

View Profile

The Vein Institute at The Cardiovascular Care Group

  • 333 Mt. Hope Avenue, Suite 207 Rockaway, NJ 07866
  • (800) 954-8346

View Profile

Cheng Du 23

  • 6 Willowbrook Blvd. Wayne, NJ 07470
  • (973) 812-2800

Authentic Sichuan Cuisine

View Profile

La Couronne Restaurant

  • 23 Watchung Plaza Montclair, NJ 07042
  • (973) 744-2090

View Profile

Solar Do Minho

  • 15 Cleveland St. Belleville, NJ 07109
  • (973) 844-0500

View Profile

Submit a correction

Know more about this business than we do? Cool! Please submit any corrections or missing details you may have.

Help us make it right

What the community has to say about Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

Information about this business (2)

Pasteurized cage-free egg yolks, sweetened condensed milk, fresh squeezed key lime juice, 100% pure butter and Graham crumbs.

Available in 10", 8", 4", 3" and Swingle!

FYI- The Key Lime (Citrus aurantifolia Swingle) is in a class all of its own. Much smaller than regular "Persian" limes, the key lime ranges in size from a ping-pong ball to a golf ball (about 10cm to16cm in circumference).The...

Native Miamian Steve Tarpin started Steve's Authentic in 1994, using only the freshest ingredients available and replicating the same key lime pie he made for family and friends over 25 years ago.

Our location IS your best bet for purchasing a pie (in terms of freshness). We start fresh every Monday, so the pies are available from Tuesday thru the weekend. We're usually here seven-days a week...

Reviews of this business (99) view all

Share a review

Overall review sentiment

Score
%

Top 3 sentiment words

Overall review sentiment

Score
%

Rating distribution

5 stars
69
4 stars
15
3 stars
3
2 stars
3
1 star
3
No rating
6
See more reputation details

Other reviews from the web (99) view all

Average Rating
100

Steve’s makes key lime pies. Nothing else. Which means the pies have been honed and perfected, until they’re the delectable little pastries you can get today. Pies are made in small batches by hand and from scratch - freshly squeezed limes and homemade crusts. The hours of operation vary and are pretty much random though, so call ahead to check if anyone’s in.

I had seen a friend pose in front of this sign on Instagram and thought, “I need to check that place out!” So I looked it up and tried to figure out a way to get myself over to Brooklyn from the city. I decided to get there by way of the New York Water Taxi. Such a great idea – the all day pas is $31 and boats run every 45 minutes. I picked up the boat at Pier 11 in lower Manhattan and took it...

Average Rating
100

Hubby bought this home as a surprise to celebrate an event. Best klp north of miami...might be better actually

Average Rating
100

The Best. Better than anything I ever had in The Keys . . . Truth.

Average Rating
100

Well worth the trip! A perfect blend of quality and taste. This is how key lime pie is done!

Business description (6) view all

Steve's Authentic is located at 204 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY. This location is in the Red Hook neighborhood. This business specializes in Bakeries.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies can be found at Van Dyke St 204. The following is offered: Food Manufacturers & Processors. The entry is present with us since Sep 9, 2010 and was last updated on Nov 14, 2013. In Brooklyn there are 45 other Food Manufacturers & Processors. An overview can be found here.

Steve's Authentic was founded in 1996, and is located at 204 Van Dyke St Ste 207 in Brooklyn. Additional information is available at www.stevesauthentic.com or by contacting Steve Tarpin at (718) 858-5333.

(718) 858-5333

Committed to bringing the best key lime pie experience to the marketplace.

© 2007-2024 Solfo, Inc. – All rights reserved