Mary's Dairy

I Love Likity Lite

Average Rating

100

They have this soft serve, Liktiy Lite, that's supposed to be no fat, and 15 calories an ounce. OMG how good is it? It's almost unbelievable that something this good could be so good for my waist line. I just hope it's not like in that Seinfeld episode. Actually who cares. I mean I only get it every other day, and then I can spin obessively. I really like this place, and th owners and staff are all so friendly and warm. I just hate those dumb tee shirts though.

Posted by rachellerose on March 30, 2007. Brought to you by Citysearch.

The Best Ice Cream Ever

Average Rating

100

Wow, where has Mary been all my life? She makes the best Ice Cream I've ever eaten. And that's no small feat. I've been at this a long time, eating Ice Cream that is. I've eaten it by the spooon, by the pint and yes I've been known to do a quart in my younger days. I've eaten homemade Ice Cream at some of the most famous places in the country. I've had Glace in France and Gellato in Italy. On the commercial side, I love Ben and Jerry's. Nothing compares to what I've just discovered at Mary's Dairy. Dense, rich with the most incredible choclate. They say they use Valrhona and Callebeaut....

Posted by realestatebroker on March 30, 2007. Brought to you by Citysearch.

Shakes and Egg Cream and Yes Ice Cream too. A dangerous place indeed.

Average Rating

100

A real Egg Cream with real seltzer from one of those old blue bottles. Makes me pine for the times I've never seen. Then there are those shakes. Thick and creamy and using that killer chocolate ice cream. Mary is a mean girl, she got me hooked, I'm addictive at heart and need a new twelve step program to wean me of this new obsession, Sandy, Belgian chocolate ice cream with pistachio halavah in it. Back in the day I smoked Opium from Turkey, now I just hallucinate on their Halavah. I tried the Yin Yang too, which is the killer chocolate ice cream with pieces of Valrhona chocolate in it....

Posted by justanotherjoe on March 30, 2007. Brought to you by Citysearch.

Average Rating

100

East or West Village you get the best when you happen into Mary's Dairy, the queen of cream. I've been eating their regular ice cream and gourmet flavors for a couple years and was happy to find that their ice cream cakes serve up the…

Posted by dougieb on March 13, 2007. Brought to you by menupix.

Ice cream Dream come true!

Average Rating

60

I was in there on Monday, March 13, 2007(visiting from Boston) and Eva and Kelly were not only AWESOME but totally HOT...the ice cream was wicked sweet, too. I come down to NY every week for business and I'm gonna visit Mary's Dairy every time!

Posted by kellbellflaher on March 12, 2007. Brought to you by Citysearch.

Marys Dairy is located at 158 1st Ave, New York, NY. This location is in the East Village neighborhood..

Posted on May 15, 2015. Brought to you by merchantcircle.

As well as ice cream, Mary's sells T-shirts.

Posted on May 09, 2007. Brought to you by Citysearch.