Sugarplum Bakery

Editorial Review

Customized cakes for weddings and birthdays as well as cupcakes can be made and sent anywhere in the NYC area.

Posted by by Contributor at Citysearch on March 07, 2007. Brought to you by Citysearch.

Magical place to bring your children

Average Rating

80

Icecream,candy,pastries and cookies galore. Some toys as well.
Seating available if you want breakfast or lunch. Food is good but not outstanding

Posted by prontobdl on October 14, 2012. Brought to you by tripadvisor.

Hair Baked into the roll

Average Rating

40

I came and got my mother some baked goods out of here and everything seemed out okay, but when I got it too her she found a piece of hair baked into the roll. It was pretty gross, and my mother told me to never come back. My first time with a bad thing to say about this place but I might give it another chance and see if they improve.

Posted by Wendy F. on December 28, 2010. Brought to you by insiderpages.

Yelp

I ordered a cake from sugarplum bakery for my daughter's 7th birthday. She loves pink and high school musical. Alicia made the most delicious and beautiful cake ever. The other mother's all wanted…

Posted by by victoria p. on June 08, 2009. Brought to you by openlist.

Amazing High School Cake

Average Rating

100

Cake was delivered to venue ahead of time. The cake was stunning, way more than we expected. The cake's detail was an incredible rendition of High School Musical, exactly what my daughter wanted for her birthday. The adults at the party were equally impressed - all wanted to know where the cake was from. I will definitely be ordering from here for my son's birthday in July - a Star Wars theme.

Pros

+ Delicious, beautiful design, wowed everyone at party

Posted by by vwpierce at Citysearch on May 27, 2009. Brought to you by Citysearch.

AMAZING and HIGHLY Reccomended

Average Rating

100

My boyfriend sent me cupcakes to the office for my birthday...they were AMAZING! Not only were they beyond tasty, they were customized to me with a logo of my company, shoes, pocket books, roses, etc. Receiving this cupcakes was 10x better than getting flowers... so thoughtful and creative!!

Pros

+ tasty, creative, accomodating

Cons

- nothing

Posted by by emb914 at Citysearch on May 06, 2009. Brought to you by Citysearch.